

Digital Learning Portfolio
William Waples

Digital Learning Portfolio
William Waples
Foundations Guided II Reflections
Week 1 January 6, 2020
​
Lesson plan analysis
A Lesson that went well - Workstations for science unit review
​
This lesson was a 2-day review of the science life systems unit. There were 6 work stations with worksheets. Students were expected to work in groups of 3-4 to complete the worksheet together using their notes and knowledge in preparation for a unit test.
This lesson worked well as it was engaging to the students and offered students an opportunity to socialize and coach each other during the lesson. For the most part they were focused on their work and were able to complete the worksheets with the help of their peers. I was able to observe the groups for their completion of the worksheet and asked questions to assess their understanding of the topic they were learning.
I contributed by developing the worksheets the students used during the lesson and ran the lesson. I taught this 2-day lesson to 4 different classes allowing me multiple opportunities to reflect on the lesson. I talked about the amount of work and preparation that was required to make the lesson and the effort required to monitor 6 groups of students working simultaneously. I also commented how to effectively divide the class in to functional groups.
Student groups were divided by academic level with the hope that would make it easier for students to engage with their peers and make it easier for me to know which groups to monitor closely. In hindsight I don’t think this was the best strategy. Groups seemed to work more effectively when there was diverse background of students where some students could act as mentors and coaches for their peers.
Lesson plan analysis
​
​
A lesson than didn’t go well – Steps in Effective writing
This lesson was a multi-part introduction to writing using a 4 steps approach: plan, draft, revise and final copy. The goal was to have students write a descriptive five sentence summary of a calendar picture chosen from a pile available to the class. The process was to take 3 half periods of language class to complete. There were a few things that didn’t go well in this lesson. First it was my first attempt to use Google classroom with the class with my AT. Neither of us fully understood how to assign a Google Classroom assignment and it took a fair bit of class time to get it set up. We used the library computers to complete the work which were old, and it took a long time for the students to start them up and get logged on. This resulted in a great deal of unproductive time in the class which was a time for students to lose focus and begin to act silly and disruptive.
I should have better understood the speed limitations of the library computers and ensured I knew how to use Google Classroom effectively well before beginning the lesson. The lesson assignment should have been created well before the class and I should have ensured the AT was comfortable using the software as I didn’t have direct access to it. In further parts of the lesson we used the newer Chromebooks. The students were much more familiar with using them and they were much quicker than the older library desktops.
January 13, 2020 Week 2
​
Step 1: Locate and summarize a peer-reviewed paper:
​
King-Sears, M. E. et. al. (2015) An exploratory study of universal design for teaching chemistry to students with and without disabilities. Learning Disability Quarterly3 38(2): 84-96.
​
Problem:
Research Question 1: Are students with and without
HID taught using a UDL treatment better able to solve
one- and two-step mole conversion problems than students
taught using comparison instruction (i.e., business
as usual)?
​
Research Question 2: Do these students maintain performance
after a 4-week delay?
-
Comparison of learning outcomes for students with and without disabilities
-
Get empirical data from implementing specific guidelines.
-
Universal design for learning (UDL) helps minimize, reduce or eliminate learning barriers.
-
In US the Higher Education Opportunity Act of 2008 defines:
-
Provide flexibility in information presentation and the manner students demonstrate skills and knowledge
-
Accommodations, supports and appropriate removal of instructional barriers while maintaining high expectations for achievement.
-
-
UDL framework by NCUDL (https://medium.com/udl-center) 3 of 9 guidelines listed:
-
Multiple means of representation (perception, language expression, symbols)
-
Multiple means of expression (physical action, expression, communication, executive expression)
-
Multiple means of engagement (recruiting interest, sustaining effort and self-regulation. Also minimize distractions
-
Experimental conditions (US based highschool chemistry class)
-
Self-management strategy (mnemonic, IDEAS)
-
IDEAS self-management system to scaffold on when and how to make a decision when solving a problem
-
-
Multi-media lessons with narration, visuals and animations
-
Procedural facilators with IDEAS for support
-
Student workbooks mirroring video and scaffolding practice problems
-
Students tested on mole converstion problems pre, post and delayed post-lesson
-
Questions scored on accuracy and conversion process on a point scale based on the difficulty of the question
-
Results and figure showing an example of the IDEAS system.
​

Conclusions:
-
High standard deviations in the results likely due to variation and small sample sizes
-
Consider these results preliminary due to lower level of associations
-
Data suggests the UDL treatment was helpful for HID students and their long term memory retention (statistically relevant by ANOVA p<0.05)
-
Data for non-HID students suggest the possibility it may hinder results, although the statistical relevance is not firm.
-
The rational and method of testing in this study is informative, but the results do not firmly support a conclusion
Step 2: Respond to the following prompts:
​
Why is it important to access information about teaching and learning from peer-reviewed sources?​
​
Able to access the latest research in the field. It is data that has passed peer-review scrutiny. As teachers part of out OCT mandate is to be self-reflective and constantly learning. We should have some knowledge of what questions in education research are being actively researched and how the research is being conducted. We also need to evaluate the effectiveness of different methods and consider what circumstances it might be beneficial to implement them into the classroom.
​
How did you choose the article you wanted to summarize?
​
I don’t have a lot of knowledge about universal design for learning (UDL) and I wanted to learn more about the subject. This was a recent article from North America that focused on the effectiveness of UDL implementation in a chemistry classroom.
​
What was the most challenging aspect of searching and summarizing?
​
There was some new terminology and jargon that I needed to learn including acronyms (e.g. HID, ULD, IDEAS). This had a sound methodology and well defined and specific research goal, but the results did not statistically support many conclusions. This was mostly due to the small sample size in the experiment and the high variability of test scores between individuals. This made it difficult to evaluate the effectiveness of the experimental conditions used in the study.
January 20, 2020 Week 3
​
​
What are your current understandings about Universal Design for Learning and Differentiated Instruction?
​
Universal design is a pedagogical principle of making classes accessible to all students. It developed from teaching methods developed to help students with learning and physical disabilities. Increasing the accessibility of lessons often helps all students in the classroom. Making a lesson more accessible is essential for some students, but the application often has a benefit to all students in the class.
​
Applying universal design in teaching can have many forms. Teachers can provide information in multiple formats. For example, a new concept might be taught with a reading, group presentation, verbal instruction, demonstration, video or with a student activity like a lab. Making a lesson more accessible is essential for some students, but the application often has a benefit to all students in the class. It provides a set of principles for planning instruction that promotes equity, flexibility and inclusiveness in their classrooms.
​
Differentiated learning focuses more specifically on the varying needs of different students in the classroom. In contrast to universal design, differentiated learning promotes student choice in response to student background, ability and preference. Understanding and responding to student skills, needs and interest is at the heart of differentiated learning. While maintaining the same curriculum goals and expectation, teachers can vary the content, process, environment and products of learning in response to class or student needs.
​
One common feature of differentiated learning is the use of flexible groupings during lessons. Groups can be freedom to learn about a topic in different ways or with different points of emphasis. The learning goals and success criteria remain the same, but the path groups take to accomplish them can be varied. For example, one group of students might prefer to learn about interactions within an ecosystem by investigating an ocean environment while another might prefer investigating a local forest ecosystem. A third might want to explore how a similar set of interactions occur at the microscopic level. All three groups can learn the same principles through different applications suited to their interests.
​
​
How can UDL and DI be beneficial to ALL of your students?
​
Giving students choices and different ways to learn can be conducive to a constructionist classroom. They are foundations for developing an equitable classroom where all students feel valued and included. When offered choice, students can be more engaged and learn to take responsibility for their learning. Motivated and empowered students are more likely to be self-motivated and engaged in class.
What challenges might you face when considering UDL and DI in your lesson and unit planning?
​
Both principles require careful planning when preparing lessons. Teachers need develop adaptive lessons that can be modified to accommodate different types of lesson delivery. The way lessons are delivered needs to change to suite the needs of the students being taught. It can be difficult to apply universal design in learning and differentiated instruction with existing lessons without some alterations. This often means more work for the teacher.
​
http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/general/elemsec/speced/LearningforAll2013.pdf
Universal Design pp 13-14. Differentiated Instruction pp 17-18
​
January 27, 2020 - Week 4
Inquiry based learning to investigate the legacy of Residential Schools in Canada
​
-
Exploring – students choose an engaging topic and develop deep questions around the topic
-
Open ended, curiosity, confusion, critical thinking, cross-disciplinary, ethically, reflective
-
Teacher asking Big Idea questions, high end thinking,
-
Teacher scaffold, student organized (KWL, RAN, anchor charts)
-
-
Investigating – Students design inquiry, find sources, select information and develop a focus
-
Variety of sources (video, text, interview, magazine, etc.)
-
Compare, evaluate, assess for bias and accuracy
-
Accountability and ongoing descriptive feedback from teachers
-
Graphic organizers (Fishbone, etc.)
-
-
Processing – Students analyze/evaluate information, organize and synthesize
-
Charts (Matrix, Venn diagram etc.) to display info
-
Determine meaning of their information
-
Points of view, missing voices, bias
-
Appropriate inferences
-
Plans of action based upon results
-
-
Creating – Create knowledge product, extend and transfer into new contexts and inquiries
-
Consider audience and connections to success criteria and learning goals. Demonstrating understanding
-
Student self-assessment and reflection. What have a learned? What have I created? Where can I progress?
-
Advocacy and community building. (school, community, country, global)
-
​
​
Click the images to see an interactive version of the infographic with functional links or download the files as a PDF
​
​
​
Why is it important that educators understand the critical importance of the tragic history of Indigenous children in Canada?
​
Education plays an important role in society. As educators we are trying to empower out students. As part of that we need to understand the legacy of education. The residential school system was initiated with the mandate to "civilize" indigenous children. In effect it was an effort to assimilate indigenous children into our culture by robbing them of their culture. It is critical that we recognize the public school system we are training to join is a decedent of the same public schooling philosophy that produced the residential school system. It is important to understand how destructive that system was to indigenous people and their communities in the hope of correcting the wrongs of the past and preventing similar tragedies from occurring again.
​
What are YOU going to do about it? What is YOUR plan of action for teaching and learning?
​
As an educator I will strive to find ways to incorporate indigenous viewpoints and history into lessons. This could include understanding Western bias, including indigenous language, history and perspective. Educators need to ensure we don't continue to perpetuate outdated notions and stereotypes that denigrate indigenous people and culture. It is my responsibility to educate myself to understand the lasting destructive legacy of colonization in Canada, to promote and to be open to change to change that will correct that legacy.​
February 17 - Week 5
​
Based on what you have heard, read and discussed, how will you approach questioning and formative assessment in your classroom?
I recently used a vector quantity as an analogy for how a teacher should influence a classroom. A vector is a physics term for a quantity that has both a direction and a magnitude. I think it serves as a way of thinking about how questions can be used to direct student thinking in a classroom. Questions, when properly used, can be effective tools to focus and direct student thinking. Like a vector they have a direction component, seeking out an answer. They also have a magnitude component in the amount of information they require to answer. A closed knowledge question seeks only one specific answer or definition, while an open-ended application question can have a multitude of possible answers.
Formative assessment can be thought of as the way teachers and students evaluate their ability to answer these questions. Growing success argues assessment should be “ongoing descriptive feedback that is clear, specific, meaningful, and timely to support improved learning and achievement” (Ontario, 2010 p .6). Formative assessment is done during the learning process, an when properly used and implemented it allows adaptive modifications on behave of both students and teachers to ensure better learning outcomes. It can provide information about misconceptions, interests, efficacy, readiness, self-regulation, strengths and weaknesses. It is essential to a learning environment that strives to be inclusive, equitable and responsive to student needs.
Through my practicum and lessons at the Faculty of Education I’ve gained a greater understanding of the importance of questioning strategies and formative assessment. Questioning strategies learned from Bloom’s taxonomy and the Edugains website allow teachers to direct, focus and modulate the intensity of student thought. It sets a stage upon which learning can be observed and assessed. Formative assessment provides a framework to observe and provide feedback for that learning. It provides information that we teachers can use to improve or adapt our teaching in response to the specific needs of our students. Teachers also need to engage students in formative self-assessment, helping them become independent learners.
Describe how are you thinking differently about teaching and learning now than you were in September of 2019.
As I progress through the program, I am gaining a greater understanding of how the learning process should be focused on encouraging independent learners. I think I was always aware of its importance, but I am becoming more aware of strategies, techniques and philosophies designed to encourage independent learners. For example, I had an aversion to using learning goals and success criteria in my lessons during my first practicum placement. I found them awkward to use and integrate into a lesson, preferring instead to use a guiding question to focus and direct my lessons to a class. With more classroom experience and better knowledge of documents like Growing Success, I have a much better understanding of their potential usefulness and the proper way to implement. They can be powerful tools to promote independent learning skills in students. They can be used to compliment self-assessment skills (assessment as learning). Through experience, repetition and practice I can better see how using learning goals and success criteria can be a valuable learning tool. I have had similar experiences with many other instructional strategies and teaching tools. Since September 2019 I’ve become better at self-assessing my own skills and weaknesses as an educator and as a student. I continue to learn how to teach learners.
​
Word cloud: Important words from researcher quotes on descriptive feedback. The image is an example of our class work and serves to make our learning and progress explicit to us students.
​

February 24 - Week 6
​
•How can an effective assessment rubric support learners of all abilities and improve both student achievement and well-being? How will your own experiences as a learner shape your rubric design for your future students?
As a leaner I appreciate a rubric that clearly defines my expected tasks and explicitly details the requirements of my assignments. It helps me focus my work. It helps define what I should be doing and what is important. It also helps give reason to what I am doing when I can see how the specific requirements related back to class expectations and learning goals. An effective assessment rubric helps me achieve by explicitly defining what I am expected to do and how I am expected to do it.
​
As a teacher having a well designed rubric helps me ensure my assignment is suited to fulfilling the learning goals for the class. It ensures I am evaluating students in a fair manner with criteria that I can refer to later to justify the mark I give. It defines that success criteria for the learning goals I want students to achieve
​
How can a rubric promote teacher and student well being? A poorly defined task can be stressful for students and teachers. Clearly defined expectations are important part of instruction. While a rubric needs to be explicit and specific in what it assesses, it can still offer flexibility for students to express their own individuality. It can allow for differentiated in how students complete the work, which can help student well-being? Perhaps they can choose the method of presentation or choose a specific topic that fits within the broader scope of the rubric. This is the type of rubric I appreciated as a student. One that balanced being explicit with offering choice.
March 2 - Week 7
​
What is your personal philosophy towards classroom management? What steps will you take to be an effective classroom manager and to create your own personal classroom culture?
​
I believe classroom management starts with knowing and developing a relationship with your students. As a teacher you need to find a way to express your personality in a constructive way, and the students need to be able to do the same. Knowing your students also helps build the classroom as an inclusive and safe space. In his theory of self-determination Edward Deci defines relatedness as feeling that you and your contributions are valued and appreciated and that you have an opportunity to value and appreciate the contributions of others. That supportive give and take is the foundations of an inclusive classroom.
​
Relatedness can be promoted by getting to know your students and allowing your students to get to know you. This doesn’t mean becoming best friends. Professionalism must be maintained. But caring and understanding can be expressed within a professional relationship. It can be promoted with simple gestures like learning the names, backgrounds and interests of students, promoting effort and growth and offering opportunities for students to express their individuality. This creates a foundation from which other components of classroom management can more easily achieved.
March 16 - Week 9
​
Consider your takeaways from the Inclusivity & Equity Conference as well as the OCT Ethical Standards for the Teaching Profession
It is easy not to consider opinions and viewpoints outside of our individual experience. This was highlighted for me in the inclusivity and equity conference. My perspective is somewhat unique from my peers as I can reflect upon the changes that have occurred since my time in school 20-30 years ago. A great deal has changed in the way classrooms are run since that time as society has become more diverse and more sensitive to the viewpoints non-mainstream groups.
​
a) What will true inclusivity look like in your classroom? Make connections to the Ethical Standards for the Teaching Profession.
​
In my mind inclusion is intricately inked with equity and diversity. Ontario’s equity and inclusive action plan (MoE, 2009) defines the three terms as follows:
DIVERSITY: The presence of a wide range of human qualities and attributes within a group, organization, or society. The dimensions of diversity include, but are not limited to, ancestry, culture, ethnicity, gender, gender identity, language, physical and intellectual ability, race, religion, sex, sexual orientation, and socio-economic status.
EQUITY: A condition or state of fair, inclusive, and respectful treatment of all people. Equity does not mean treating people the same without regard for individual differences. ]
​
INCLUSIVE EDUCATION: Education that is based on the principles of acceptance and inclusion of all students. Students see themselves reflected in their curriculum, their physical surroundings, and the broader environment, in which diversity is honoured and all individuals are respected.
A teacher’s mandate to uphold the values of these terms is outlined in the Ontario College of Teacher’s ethical standards for the teaching profession. As teachers we are expected to show and promote care, respect, trust and integrity in out classes schools, and communities (OCT, n.d.).
b) Search for and provide a resource that will help you and your colleagues develop an inclusive classroom.
​
Ontario Ministry of Education Equity, Diversity and Inclusivity Links
​
This is the link to the Ontario Ministry of Education’s equity resource site. It offers official mission statements and policy documents including the Ontario’s Equity and Inclusive Education Strategy and Ontario’s education equity action plan.